Showing posts with label Eaton Socon Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Eaton Socon Church. Show all posts

Friday, April 20, 2012

When does a repair becomes a replacement

First St Mary's Eaton Socon Church wants a car park and gets one. Now they want a replacement boundary wall. And the Council Taxpayer will be forking out for this.

In the minutes for the Town Council Operations and Amenities Committee the following is minuted:

(ii) Repairs to the Church Wall at St Mary’s Church, Eaton Socon.
The Acting Town Clerk had spoken to Reverend Timothy Robb who had confirmed that the only option they would consider would be a replacement wall. A meeting had been arranged with a neighbouring resident and planning and conservation officers from HDC at the end of the month.

From what I have read, the Town Council has the responsibility to maintain and repair the boundary wall. There is nothing here about the replacement of the boundary wall which remains the property of the Church.

Maintain: Keep (something) at the same level or rate.
Repair:  Fix or mend (a thing suffering from damage or a fault).
Replacement: The action or process of replacing something.

I contend the Town Council has a duty to repair and maintain the boundary wall. I also contend it doesn't have a duty to replace the wall. That is the duty of the owner of the land. And the owner of the land is the Church.

In its 2010 accounts (the annual update was received 23 days late) shows the Church received £17,499 in recovered income tax. Whilst it lost just over £14,261 the church also spent £26,421 on re-building the pipe organ.

In the end it will be the Council taxpayer that picks up the bill for a wall that is owned by the church. If the Church wants a replacement wall then the church should pay for a replacement wall and let the Town Council Taxpayer stump up for maintaining and repairing the wall as required by law. 

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Mandy doesn't do it again!

As ever the elusive Mandy Thomas has missed yet another meeting at HDC and continues to pick up her pay cheque for doing nothing. Mandy was supposed to be at HDC's Economic Well-being OSP on Thursday 10th March 2011. This time Mandy sent her apologies for not attending. Fine but that doesn't mean much. Mandy hasn't attended a Council or Committee meeting since 15th July 2010. Is this a record for not attending? If Mandy isn't going to turn up to Council meetings then what is the point of her continuing on the District Council. Oh yes the pay cheque and the free computer. The Conservatives are quick to jump on those who live off the state. When it is one of their own they keep very, very quiet. The time has gone when Mandy should have resigned. Mandy is elected until May 2012. It looks as though the Council taxpayer is going to keep Mandy to the life she has become accustomed to for another 14 months!

I just don't understand why the Conservatives let her stay in the party. Mandy is hardly contributing yet the Conservatives let here hang on. Time they got rid of Mandy from the Conservative Group for starters.

Remember what Mandy said:

Sunday, December 12, 2010

More on the Church Car Park.

The Church Car Park outside St Mary's, Eaton Socon, which hit the headlines with the Church wanting the Council Taxpayer to pay for their car park, has been resurfaced. This has been paid for by the Town Council using a large grant from Tesco.

The Church must me laughing at the Council taxpayer having got one over the Town Council who will have to maintain this church car park. I still maintain this is a car park for the Church. As can be seen by these photos it is the church sign which is the only prominent sign. There is no Town Council sign informing users that it is a Town Council car park for the use of all the residents. Nor is their a sign informing people the car park was mainly paid for by Tesco. The only sign up was the St Mary's Church Noticeboard which makes the car park look like a car park for the church. Also I found no Council notices so anyone can park at this car park for free as long as they like as there are no restrictions. Plus there is no notice up about responsibility. So the Town Council takes responsibility for any damage to cars parked there? No sign up to say otherwise.
Is the church that poor that it couldn't afford this car park? In their accounts for 2009 the Parochial Church Council had enough money to fund these improvements. There were £17,825 in unrestricted funds at the year end (31/12/09). What is interesting in all this is how much the Church relies on the Taxpayer for some of it's funding through Gift Aid.
So the taxpayer has to stump up to keep the Church going through Gift Aid, the maintenance of the closed churchyard and now the car park. Good deal for the church. Bad deal for the council taxpayer.

Friday, February 12, 2010

Who owns the land?

I was struck by a comment by Town Cllr Barry Chapman. On the St Neots Community Forum Cllr Chapman pointed out the following:

"As for comments about whether it is the church car park or not - I refer to "my street" it doesn't imply I think I own it!"

How true this is. I also refer to the street where I live as my street. I do try to take care of my street. I report problems like abandoned cars and street lights out. Whilst I want my environment to be good referring to the street I live in as my street doesn't mean or imply I own it.

So what would imply that I either owned or controlled a property? Some examples:

If you saw this sign on a wall who do you think owns or controls this building? 
Answer: St Neots Town Council? And you would be right.

Another example:

If you saw the sign pictured below on fence who do you think would owns or controls the land?
Answer: St Neots Town Council? And you would be correct.

Last example.

If you saw this noticeboard in front of a car park who would you think owns or controls the land?
Answer: St Mary's Eaton Socon? Wrong! Diocese of St Albans? Wrong! or even the Church of England? Wrong! The correct answer is St Neots Town Council.

Having a large sign at the entrance to a piece of land implies to me that you own or control the land. Some Church users refer to this piece of land as the church car park. With this sign at the entrance I can see why they think so! Now the car park needs repair it changes from a church car park to a community car park which hard pressed council taxpayers is called on to pay for repairs.

Once the church car park issue is resolved I feel the church will still have this sign up implying it controls the car park.

Saturday, February 6, 2010

Letter in the News and Crier 4/2/10

I'm commenting on letters in this weeks edition of the News and Crier. The letters are on Page 7.

No to car park charges - Cllr Bob Farrer has come out against the car parking charges at Riverside Car Park, St Neots. Conservative Cllr Farrer is saying that his colleagues have reneged on a previous decision to keep this Car Park free. Cllr Farrer also has a dig at the Conservatives colleagues on the set up of the Working Party. He feels the fact that a two members were married this is totally undemocratic?! This is somewhat at odds with a report which says: 3.1 The Working Party debated the proposals made and also received input from local Ward Members who attended the meeting. 

Cllr Farrer goes onto write: "Be assured, I, along with other local councillors, will not except (accept) that charges should be introduced to this car park."

The problem is how far is Councillor Farrer and his Conservative colleagues are willing to go. The question I have is if they are so against this are they going to vote against the budget at cabinet and/or Council.

In the second part of the letter Cllr Farrer goes on to attack the Liberal Democrats Town Council for not taking on the Public Conveniences. The Conservative controlled HDC tried to dump this service on the Town Council after reneging on a decision to keep this service. Cllr Farrer should be having another go at his Conservative colleagues about stopping this service rather than blaming the Liberal Democrats.

Don't stop church parking - Linda Walton writes: "I would like to say I have never used the library, the fire service, the police helicopter - I could go on - but I am paying tax too!"

None of which are services paid for by the Town Council. These services are there for the benefit of the whole community provided by public authorities as all public services are. The Church is not a public service. The church wants this car park and wants the taxpayer to fund this. Whilst I have seen many emotional reasons for the Council Taxpayer pouring money into a new car park, I don't see a case being made for taxpayer cash to prop up this church.

Biggest ward, smallest share - This letter is about the politics of envy which always costs the taxpayer loads of money. Rather than being between the envy of St Neots and Huntingdon we have the envy between The Eatons and Eynesbury. One further thought on Eynesbury Hardwicke. They paid little or zero council tax to their Parish Council. The question should not be aimed at SNTC but to the annexed residents as to why they didn't build these facilities under their old regime.

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Letters in the Hunts Post 03/02/10

I have some comments on letters in this edition of the Hunts Post. These are:

Website costs will be clear - Cllr Jonathan Gray starts talking about the new website. I agree with him that the website needs to change. But my gripe with the new website has been the number of errors I found wherever I looked. These problems are still happening. After requesting some information from HDC I was told the following:

"Ordinarily this would have appeared on our website, but we are unfortunately experiencing some problems with uploading new information."

Secrecy seems to be the order of the day in HDC. As Cllr Gray says: "I authorised this information to be passed to him". So why does Cllr Gray need to authorise another District Councillor to see this information which should be made public?

What grounds? - Another letter having a go at the Town Council over the Church Car Park on the village green at Eaton Socon. Whilst I do feel the use of Health and Safety was over the top in relation to the stopping of the car parking, I feel the church should pay for the car park. Nigel Appleton poses this question: 

"Is this the same council that shamefully neglected to grit the completely iced over and steep exit ramp from the Riverside Car Park during the recent bad weather?". The simple answer is NO! 

The long answer is this is a car park owned by HDC and is therefore it is HDC responsibility and NOT the Town Council. Nigel should look at the car park signs before BLAMING the WRONG COUNCIL.

Invest Wisely - I see that Rosemary Cockrill has started the internal them (Eaton Socon/Ford) and us (Eynesbury) dispute. Eaton Ford gets a community centre so Eynesbury has to have a Community Centre. This is the politics of envy. Looking at the ECC there seems to be little demand for this community centre. Eynesbury would have the same problems. I don't hear of any real demand for a centre. The politics of envy invariably costs the council taxpayer money as unnecessary buildings are built and services are provided.

Friday, January 29, 2010

Letters in the News and Crier 27/01/10

Rather than doing a separate piece on each letter so I thought I would lump all I want to comment on into one article. Link to the ever excellent News and Crier.

Outrage at candidate's 'offensive remarks' - This blog started this story and the News and Crier picked this up. Bill Sinclair is right. Though whether this is slanderous is a moot point. James Clark should read the original article before firing off a letter.

Community should pay - Malcolm McColl is right to say Tesco should be asked for a contribution. The church pays the rest. As for Helen Cochrane's letter, I will repeat that it if the church wants this car park then the Church should pay. Has it got to be that everytime something is used by "the community" the taxpayer must then pick up the bill? I don't think so. Will Helen support all churches which have or want a car park get these paid for and maintained by the taxpayer? It is very easy to call for taxpayers to pick up the bill because there is no direct relationship. But one of the consequences doing something for the 'community' is in next letter.

Anger at £270k hole - St Ives Town Council is run by Independent Councillors. I think that is worth saying. The trouble is the Corn Exchange. These Independent Councillors were elected to stop the building being sold and set about refurbishing it for the 'community'. When Councils do things for the 'community' it cost money and Council tax goes up.
In answer to the letter, Parish and Town Councils are NOT included in the capping arrangements. In theory they could tax us more and more. My worry is that HDC, with all its financial problems, will look at what a Town/Parish can do and try to shift services and costs to the Towns and Parishes. This is what HDC did with the Public Conveniences.

Did they want a lap dog - A much better letter from Paul Dakers than the one printed in the Hunts Post. I can understand the frustration with the political process when you are at the bottom. The political parties/councillors/councils build up their respective roles. The reality is what Councils can do is restricted by law and many major decisions are taken by Government.
 The trouble with Cllr Monk is he is a political tramp. Started with the Conservatives, went Independent and has ended up in UKIP.  Probably not the end of his journey.

Fewer jobless than in 1992 - Labour Parliamentary candidate is again in the papers. This time with an outright political letter. What Anthea doesn't mention is the Government is likely to borrow in this current financial year at total of £180,000,000,000. That is scary! 

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

When does a church car park become a community car park?


Answer: When the church wants to the Town Council to pay for it!

In an article in this weeks Hunts Post, Richard De Fraine, a church council member is quoted as saying:

"I think it is incredibly short-sighted of the council to revert this space to village green all for the sake of a relatively small sum of money, in the scheme of things, which would allow it to be maintained as a community facility." snrednek says: If it is such a small amount of money for 'their'* car park why doesn't the church pay for this?

 "I am concerned for the young families who use the church in the week having to find alternative safe locations to load and unload their children." snrednek says: If you have such 'concerns' why didn't the church bring forward a plan to provide and pay for a car park.

"It is a well-used community car park, used by visitors to the village, the Tesco store and the church." snrednek says: In a previous article I showed the Church considered this unofficial car park as their own church car park. Obviously when it comes to paying for this it is a church car park until it has to be paid for.

"The council just seems to making its decision on costs alone and not looking at the long-term benefit to the community." snrednek says: But what of the Church? Isn't the Church looking at the cost rather than providing a car park  which would of a long term benefit to the church and maybe the community!

* In an earlier post I showed the church viewed the car park as their car park. http://snrednek.blogspot.com/2009/12/another-subsidy-for-church.html

Saturday, January 9, 2010

More on Eaton Socon Church Car Park.


The Town Council decided on 6th January 2010 to stop parking on this area. This decision will mean the land will be returned to the village green. The area will be grassed over and access will be provided for the church which has a right of vehicle access.

But I still don't see why the Town Council (therefore the council taxpayer) is paying for all this? I can understand that the Town Council has been compliant in this "church car park". They have from time to time maintained this "Church Car Park". As I pointed out in a previous post the Church has a right of way over the village green. In exercising that right the Church has to reinstate the ground it uses. I don't see why the Council taxpayers have to foot the bill for users of this church to use of this "church car park".

At the Council meeting (6/1/10) the Conservative Town Councillors seemed to want to go for the grasscrete of option. This would have meant the a large cost for someone. Guess what? Most of the cost would fall on the Town Council!

Grasscrete blocks
There were some vague noises about asking Tesco for a contribution to the cost. But hold on my a minute. Where is the contribution from the church for something they consider as "their car park"? The Conservative Councillors have had months to come up with alternative proposals and costings.

I don't care whether this piece of land is a green or a car park. I just don't see why the burden has to fall on the Council taxpayer!

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

Simply Complicated Budgets discussed tonight!


The two draft budgets are the up for discussion tonight at a Special Meeting of the Town Council. If you need to know when give the SNTC HQ a call on: (01480) 388911. It is normally about 7.00pm but it depends on what other meetings are on. The link to the TC agenda is here. According to the agenda the meeting will be discussing

Unless the Town Council is willing to cut services and employees there is very little room for manoeuvre.
Cutting back on capital projects will just store up problems for the future. Whilst tempting to cut, the Town Council should keep making resources available for the upkeep and renewal of its buildings and facilities.

What is essential is the Town Council sets a budget which reflects the costs and upkeep of its services it is to provide. The other temptation is to use reserves to keep down the net cost of the budget. This would be a retrograde step.

A Council with this number of staff doing what it is doing will cost between £950k - £1 million (These figures includes a higher capital spend and taking on public toilets, both currently excluded). Unpalatable as it is, the only way to keep down costs is to cut staff and services. This means Central Administration and Grounds Maintenance will have to be cut. Put together these have increased by over £150,000* pa in the last two years. If a majority of our Town Councillors don't want to cut services and staff then our Councillors will have to bear any political costs.

The financial jiggery pokery mainly, but not totally, under the Giles and Thorpe regime only stored up troubles for the future. Talk about efficiency savings could be good but is not the answer to underlying problems of this Town Council.

As for the The Church Car Park, this should not happen and will be a waste of money if it does.
As for the Public Toilets. SNTC cannot afford without putting up the Council tax. Don't do it!

As for the meeting itself, I'm in two minds whether to go. The last meeting I attended made Dibley Parish Council look competent.

Documents
TC Agenda - 15/12/09
Option 1 Summary
Option 2 Summary
ECC Option 1
ECC Option 2
Salary Increase

* Ground Maintenance is £83k higher than in 2008/09 budget. Administration is £68k higher over 2009/10 budget.

Monday, December 7, 2009

Another subsidy for a Church?

On the Town Council draft budget for 2010/11 there is a sentence which says:
"There is no Provision in this budget for public toilets or the Eaton Socon Car Park"


So the Town Council is thinking about doing something to the "Car Park" outside St Mary's Church, Eaton Socon! But why?

The land is owned by SNTC and is part of the Eaton Socon Village Green. As council taxpayers we pay for the upkeep of this piece of land. The church has a right of way from the public highway to the entrance gate of the church lands. But there is no right to park cars on this land. So the only use of this land is as public open space.

The church and church members seem to think otherwise. On their Facebook wall page they say the following:
"Unfortunately the council think the pot holesin our car park have become a heath and safty issue and have asked us to close it."

"Please be aware that the Town Council have today, Wednesday, closed the church car park "until further notice". This is in response to a written complaint on health and safety grounds over the condition of the surface. The issue will be discussed at a Town Council meeting next week when perhaps a less draconian option may emerge. Meanwhile, we have no car park."

Hold on there. This is public land the church members are claiming as "their car park". And they seem to expect the Town Council has to maintain this car park for their exclusive use.

And so does at least one Town Councillor in this Hunts Post article. In it Cllr Ursell is quoted as saying:

"I think it is wrong that the church should be put to inconvenience because we (SNTC) have failed to maintain a car park. We should get the access reopened immediately and carry out maintenance work on the car park as soon as possible. This is an emergency and we must not delay." 

But this website says something different. What it says is the Church has a vehicular right of way and should pay to maintain the land it uses. It further tells me that car parking is not a right! So it is up to the church to pay for the upkeep of the car park and vehicular right of way! So why is the Town Council yet again subsidising a church? I don't know but I will ask this question in the future.

The church must pay for the maintenance of the car park and right of way. Not the Town Council!

Websites and documents
St Mary's Church
St Mary's Church Facebook page
Copy of Facebook page
Boundary Problems Website