Showing posts with label Forward Plan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Forward Plan. Show all posts

Sunday, October 24, 2010

St Ives is organising a Town Plan - So why is St Neots left behind?

St Ives Town Council is looking to shape their community for the future through a Town Plan. So why hasn't St Neots got a Town Plan to shape the future of our Town? The simple answer is we could have had a proper Town Plan, but the Liberal Democrats dumped this Town Plan idea when their budget fell apart.
The Town Council even put money aside. £30,000 was put aside and another £30,000 was forecast to be used to produce a proper Town Plan.
The Liberal Democrats Forward Plan informed the public that this was "essential" and would be a "bottom up" community based Town Plan. So what did the Liberal Democrats do with this Town Plan. Well, when the budget fell apart the Liberal Democrats dumped this idea. So not as "essential" as the Liberal Democrats claimed.
This was decided at the fateful 21/01/2009 Council Meeting where the Liberal Democrats inability to manage the finances came home to roost.

The only reason the St Neots hasn't got an "essential" Town Plan is because Cllrs Giles and Thorpe dumped the plan to start to dig themselves out of the mess they found themselves in. This was done with no other announcement and has never been acknowledged in the future Forward Plans. This is Liberal Democrat run Government all over. Build us up with promises and then silence as the cuts rain down.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

So the Town Council accounts didn't come out too well!

I see the Town Council ran into a number of criticisms over the way the Town Council is run. According to the News and Crier the Town Council was criticised over:


Grant Thornton said: "The reporting of the financials in a timely, reliable and meets the needs of local people." I've been going on about the bad service St Neots residents have been receiving since the start of this blog back on 3rd November 2010. What I said back then was: "What I found by reading this was a whole bunch of meetings had taken place without the agendas being published on their website." It never got much better than that with missing meeting from the website throughout the year. The Town Council knew there was a problem and did nothing about it.

Grant Thornton said: "The non-existence of a medium term plan." The Town Council used to have a forecast in the first Forward Plan. But the Liberal Democrats messed this up. What I said about the first Forward Plan was: "The budget forecasts was a load of muck and could never be relied on. I do realise that this is a forecast. A Council cannot just make wild budget forecasts. Changes in the budget forecast and other variations must be able to be identified and reported. This didn't happen."

Grant Thornton said: "Not publishing the key financial documents on its website." The Town Council replied that the website was being rebuilt. But what the Town Council forgets is this was the case during the 2009/10 financial year. 6 months on from the end of the financial year and the Town Council is only now rebuilding the website. - Shockingly bad excuse.

Grant Thornton said: "The Forward Plan has only limited details of future financial plans."
This is what I said on my blog back on 20th August 2010 after finally finding a "Forward Plan": "The second missing section is the forward financial projections."

What really puzzles me is Cllr Chapman and his rants.

With the building of the ECC there would be a change in the balance sheet as the Town Council took on a loan of £450,000. The £120,000 budget savings mainly came from a cut in staffing levels - some of which were to the detriment of the Town Council. What I can't fathom out is the following:
Except this was for the 2009/10 accounts. The residents of Love's Farm and Eynesbury Manor weren't actually annexed until the beginning of 2010/11 financial year. So Councillor Barry Chapman is spinning false information.

snrednek says: The freedom loving Liberal Democrats aren't so freedom loving when it comes to communicating with residents. They would rather have robes for the Town Mayor than a properly functioning website communicating with and informing residents. Under the Liberal Democrats this Town Council has had a bumpy ride. Whilst many of the problems were inherited, it was their inaction over resolving these problems that exacerbated the situation. This report only confirms what I've said in another blog entry, that this Liberal Democrat run Town Council is rudderless and leaderless.

Friday, August 20, 2010

The hidden "Forward Plan" finally revealed

Forward Plan V3.pdf - Google Docs

I've recently received a copy of Version 3 of the Town Council Forward Plan. I had to ask for it as it hasn't been publicised in "Priorities" - the non Town Council publication or anywhere else. This Forward Plan - there is no published Version 2 - makes interesting reading for what it has missed out rather than what it actually says. Lets go through the less interesting information first.

Page 1. - The introduction by Cllr Thorpe, Town Mayor. In this piece we are informed the Forward Plan has "Council's plans and aspirations...". He goes onto inform us of "Much has been accomplished in the past three years". The Town Mayor goes onto say: "Your views are valued..."

Pages 5, 6 and 7 - The title of this section changes all the way through It starts off with: Objective enablers for 2010/11. Then goes onto Objective enablers for 2009/10. Seeing this was passed in March 2010 the "Forward Plan" can hardly be about 2009/10.

Page 6. - We are informed the ECC will become self supporting. I don't understand what this means. I can only take this to mean that the ECC will not now cost the Town Council anything.

Page 7. - Expansion of the Town Boundaries and working with, now defunct Parish Councils, is utterly meaningless.

Future Projects - Pages 9 to 10. Where is the swimming pool project? This is likely to be on Town Council land.

Consultation - Page 18 - We are informed by The Town Council that:
The Town Council goes onto say: ".. and to encourage residents to participate in the consultation process, the Council is:"

Placing the Forward Plan on the Town Council's website - No they didn't!
Making copies available to residents at Council Offices - I didn't see any!
Attending the Annual Town Meeting - The Forward Plan wasn't even mentioned at the Annual Town Meeting!

This is a "Catch 22" situation. You can comment on the Forward Plan. But the Forward Plan isn't available to the public. So how can residents comment on a Forward Plan?

What is missing?

There are three main sections that have been missed out of this "Forward Plan". The first section missed is a look at the previous Plan and what was and wasn't achieved. Some of what wasn't achieved is listed below:

New Cemetery to be developed and acquired by Autumn 2009.
Eatons Community Centre completed and open in Spring 2009.
Acquire land for new allotments by Spring 2009.
Relaunch the Youth Town Council.
Grant Aid increasing by inflation.
Town Plan cover 10 years.
One Stop Shop.
Town Lottery.
Town Wardens.
Support our Staff by achieving Investors in People by Summer 2009.

Some of the above was eventually achieved in a different form such as the Cemetery extension. The ECC was delayed. Others such as NOT supporting the staff by achieving Investors in People (indeed not knowing about this objective at the last Annual Town Meeting) or the Town Plan need explanations as to why these were not achieved.

The second missing section is the forward financial projections. The fundamental problem with the first Forward Plan was many of the promises were not included in the forward financial projections. This meant that decisions were being taken on the budget which looked good on paper but, in reality, were unable to be financed without large increases in Council Tax. The Liberal Democrats baulked at this prospect and slashed projects.

The third missing section is looking to the future. For a Forward Plan there is little in it about the forward direction the Town Council is taking and substantial plans rather the wishful aspirations. 

This Forward Plan just shows the Liberal Democrats have lost their way over the Town Council. Unable or unwilling to publicise this Forward Plan just tells me Liberal Democrats are jsut plain embarrassed by this document. Instead the Town Council is reduced to doing petty things, such as The Mayor's Robes, this Town Council is leaderless and rudderless. And that is down to the party that is currently in charge!

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Draft Forward Plan Mark 2


With the failure of the first Forward Plan, this long awaited revision is finally getting here. I was told back on 6th May 2009 by Councillor Gordon Thorpe that: "I believe that I have covered the major projects and objectives detailed in the Forward Plan which incidentally will be updated and released soon." Soon is so far 7 months and still counting.

Having read Draft Forward Plan MkII, I see many errors, some omissions and a few items I don't understand.

At the Town Council meeting on 6th January 2010, Cllr Julia Hayward was talking about the plan being "aspirations"(A definition: strong desire, longing, or aim; ambition). This is downgrading the Objectives and Projects. If these are Aspirations then these should be marked as such. Otherwise how are readers of this Forward Plan supposed to distinguish between an Aspiration or an Objective/Project. This is wrong!

Now there seems to be a problem over the period this plan covers. If the Plan had been produced back in May 2009 then it would have been a little late. Now in January 2010 it is too late for 2009/10. The plan should be looking ahead to 2010/11 and be integrated into the budget process.

Cover Page: 2009/11
Page 1: Forward Plan for 2009/10. So what is the plan period?
Page 5:
1. Community Centres -We will investigate possible provision of community centres in other areas of the town not already served. - If these are just aspirations how much can be investigated when there is no money?
2. New Cemetery - We will seek to develop a new cemetery by Autumn 2009. Well it is 2010 so why is this in the Forward Plan?
3. Grounds Maintenance - We will bring Grounds Maintenance completely in-house and provide a new depot to store the new machinery in the current financial year. I thought this was done in 2008/09. Does this mean there is another depot on the way with more new machinery?

Page 8 - Project Details
1.a The Eatons Community Centre. ....estimated completion Autumn 2009. But in Page 5 - 1 the aim of completion is Winter 2009. Two different dates?
1.b Eynesbury community Centre. This seems to be an aspiration. There is no money for this project, so is it really a project?
1.c Love's Farm Community Centre. ...However that sum (£350,000) will be insufficient to provide a suitable building. I feel this is wrong. £350,000 is the budget. Get on with it. 
2. New Cemetery- I do read a history of what has gone wrong. I don't see anything about a project!

Page 9 - Project Details
4. Allotments - Lots of history. The project seems to be about pursuing additional sites only in 2009/10. So not in 2010/11?
6. Festival - Again lots of history. The Council will organise and promote an enlarged Festival in 2009,... . So nothing new!
6a Christmas Lights - Again history.

Page 10 - Project details.
9. Additional Bus Shelters - Again history.
11. Priory Centre Refurbishments - Again history.

Page 11 - Project Details
12. Cinema - ...long been an aspiration. So this is not a project. So why is this in the project section?
13. The Council Constitution - Why is this a project? This something the Council should be doing. This is just filler!
14. Town Outdoor Swimming Pool - This is not a Town Council project. So why is this included. Filler!
-------------------------
Much of what I have read in this Forward Plan Mark 2 is filler. When I take out all the filler and history there isn't much left. I also cannot find any explanation as to what happened to the previous Forward Plan.
-------------------------
The Council's Budget. (Page 12). This is an outline for the 2009/10 Budget. This is now out of date because they have just passed a budget for 2010/11. The pie chart (Page 13) is an excellent graphic of how the budget is split up. Pages 14,15,16,17 and 18 continue on the budget theme but are all out of date!

Documents:
Forward Plan Mark II
First Forward Plan

Sunday, December 13, 2009

We need a Town Plan!

One of the cuts made by the Liberal Democrats to the Town Council 2008/09 budget was the Town Plan. With St Neots going to expand and expand residents need to have a say in the coming expansion. In the first Forward Plan, a Town Plan was envisaged. This is an idea I supported and the fact SNTC needed to put £60,000 aside to achieve a Town Plan I also supported. I was very disappointed when the Liberal Democrats cut this. I can't see the Liberal Democrats re-instating the provision for a Town Plan.

If St Neots residents want influence on how the Town develops, the Town Plan is the way forward. If not HuntsDC will carry on with their vision!

An example: Wivenhoe Town Plan

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

The first Forward Plan explained


As part of ending to the Best Value regime the Town Council introduced "The Forward Plan". Best Value was introduced to the Town Council level to replace Compulsory Competitive Tendering. This proved costly to the 41 Town Councils (known as the 41 Group) which fell under the Best Value Regime. The Government gave each local council a £30,000 pa grant to cover the costs of Best Value. This grant ended when the requirement to do Best Value ended.

As an aside, SNTC had a choice. It had just lost £30,000 of income. Instead of making someone redundant to cut £30,000 of expenditure it was decided to add the £30,000 to the Council Tax bill.

Back to the Forward Plan.

The Forward Plan is the most useful document the Town Council produces. The plan will show the direction the Town Council is going. By quantifying the planned projects this allows the Town Council to plan for the resources that will be needed. This is a very useful tool for residents and local politicians. The plan will show how the projects will effect future budgets and Council Tax. If the local politicians don't like the future they can either balk at the costs and cancel projects or they can stand by the tax increases. That is if the plan is done properly.

The trouble with the first Forward Plan was it wasn't a proper plan. It was a real muck up. Because of this Liberal Democrat (Giles and Thorpe) run Town Council got into a right mess.

To start with The Objectives (pages 6 to 9) numbered 24. The Project details (pages 10 to 18) didn't match the Objectives. So what was missed?

In Objectives and not in Projects:
Allotments, Farmers' Market, Town Centre Events, Grant Aid, Anglia in Bloom, Partnerships, Swimming Pool, Corporate Governance Review, Expansion of Town Boundaries and Support our Staff.

In Projects but not in Objectives:
Love's Farm Community Centre, Play Ground Upgrades, Town Christmas Lights.

This mismatch of Objectives and Projects is at the core of what was wrong. If Giles and Thorpe had got to grips with the core part of the plan the outturn would have been different. Because the resources identified as needed to progress and achieve these Objectives must go into the budget forecasts.

The problem is some of the Objectives and Projects weren't included in projected budgets (forecasts) or the resources needed weren't properly identified. Some of what was missed:

Eatons Community Centre - underfunded by at least £150,000.
Ground Maintenance - Despite a study underfunded by £95,000 pa.
Town Wardens - No resources allocated.
Town Swimming Pool - No resources allocated.
Love's Farm Community Centre - No resources allocated. A loan was alluded to but not how much.

Other problems with the budget forecast was:

Underfunding of Central Costs.
Bank Interest was went up year on year except much of the money was to be spent on the ECC. This meant the was gone but the interest was still added to the forecast as if the money was still these. So this figure was overstated by £30,000 p.a.

The budget forecasts was a load of muck and could never be relied on. I do realise that this is a forecast. A Council cannot just make wild budget forecasts. Changes in the budget forecast and other variations must be able to be identified and reported. This didn't happen.

So who is responsible for this muck up. This is actually rather easier than I thought. Under the Councils' own Standing Orders 65 - 3 -d - The Leader of Council (at the time Cllr Derek Giles) is: to be responsible for the development of the Forward Plan, its review and update. 

So Cllr Giles is in the frame for this Muck Up. I did notice Cllr Gordon Thorpe did introduce this item to Town Council for adoption. So he must have thoroughly understood what he was presenting! Didn't he?

The forthcoming revision of the Forward Plan needs to address the issue of matching resources to projects. The budget forecasts will need to be robust. I say forthcoming? Cllr Thorpe told residents: "I believe that I have covered the major projects and objectives detailed in the Forward Plan which incidentally will be updated and released soon." That was on 6th May 2009.

Forward Plan Document
Town Council Standing Orders