As someone who follows the antics of the useless Town Council Planning Committee I was somewhat taken aback by Margaret Cooke in her letter to the Hunts Post. In the letter Margaret Cooke says:
Why does she think the council planners voted against this development. Was it for the fun of it or could there be genuine reasons why this happened?
Having got hold of the minutes of the Town Council Planning Committee where the cinema proposal was voted down I have must have been for fun as there were no genuine reasons for refusal given.
As can be seen from the minutes there are no reasons given for refusal. Whilst the useless Town Council Planning Committee voted against the cinema development there is little to back up this refusal. What has been said in the press about the reasons for refusal are useless arguments.
Now if the residents really wanted to stop this scheme they should have started back when the consultation over the development brief started. The residents could have put up candidates at the elections in May. The residents could have lobbied their councillors. The residents could have gone to Town Council meetings and protested at the lease of land to Turnstone Estates. The residents could have applied for Shady Walk to become a Town Green.
If the development goes ahead all the residents against this scheme have done is to get a petition together and object. Not much else. The political class in St Neots is for the cinema scheme. HDC including its Planning Department is for the scheme. With the decision due for the Development Management Panel Meeting of 19th December 2011. This could be an early Christmas present for someone and a awful Christmas for others.
Showing posts with label SNTC Planning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SNTC Planning. Show all posts
Tuesday, October 25, 2011
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
Useless Town Council Planning Committee being useless again - Part 4
In my series of on the useless Town Council Planning Committee I thought I would highlight a couple of more decisions by the Town Council Planning Committee and how these are disregarded by the District Council Planning Department. At the Development Management Panel meeting 21st March 2011 two "refusals" have been disregarded by the District. These are:
1002012FUL
The Town Council said:
What did CCC Highways say:
The Town Council Planning Committee recommends refusal because of traffic but CCC Highways say OK.
Another traffic objection was used on 1100025FUL:
The Town Council said:
The District Council said:
If 2 spaces are created then where is the loss of parking amenity? As for County Highways they say:
Time and again the Town Council Planning Committee shows it doesn't know much about Planning. So why continue with this pantomime. Cut this committee and all the Officer time that goes into producing these reports, meetings and minutes. It is a sheer waste of time and effort. Yet the Town Council clings to this like it is the rasion d'etre of the Town Council.
1002012FUL
The Town Council said:
What did CCC Highways say:
The Town Council Planning Committee recommends refusal because of traffic but CCC Highways say OK.
Another traffic objection was used on 1100025FUL:
The Town Council said:
The District Council said:
If 2 spaces are created then where is the loss of parking amenity? As for County Highways they say:
Time and again the Town Council Planning Committee shows it doesn't know much about Planning. So why continue with this pantomime. Cut this committee and all the Officer time that goes into producing these reports, meetings and minutes. It is a sheer waste of time and effort. Yet the Town Council clings to this like it is the rasion d'etre of the Town Council.
Labels:
HDC Planning,
SNTC Planning
Monday, March 14, 2011
When will the Town Council have one policy?
I was amused by the latest utterances from the St Neots Town Council (useless) Planning Committee. Under planning item 4 the planning committee went back to their old ways of using the traffic congestion objection without any evidence. They don't like the proposed development behind 7 Eaton Socon Green. What the useless planning committee went onto say is:
The useless planning committee objects to this application because of a reduction of green space and trees. Yet the Town Council is quite happy to give up 40% to 100% of the land it owns at Shady Walk Open Space for a car park!
If the Town Council was being consistent it wouldn't be using the "reduction of green space" reason for objecting to this planning application. The Town Council is all for the cinema project which will increase traffic movements on the site and reduced green space but on non Town Council land it objects!
The useless planning committee objects to this application because of a reduction of green space and trees. Yet the Town Council is quite happy to give up 40% to 100% of the land it owns at Shady Walk Open Space for a car park!
If the Town Council was being consistent it wouldn't be using the "reduction of green space" reason for objecting to this planning application. The Town Council is all for the cinema project which will increase traffic movements on the site and reduced green space but on non Town Council land it objects!
Labels:
Cinema,
Liberal Democrats,
SNTC Planning
Saturday, January 15, 2011
Useless Town Council Planning Committee shown to be Useless again!
I support the decision over the proposed development of hardstandings at the Caravan and Camping site by the Town Council Planning Committee to approve this proposal. In this instance this shows common sense by the TC Planning Committee. HDC Planning Officers have recommended REFUSAL of this proposal and in doing so this shows why the TC Planning Committee is utterly useless.
The reason why HDC Planning Officers are recommending refusal is simply another statutory consultee, The Environment Agency, has said it should be refused because the land is liable to flooding. This seems a bit odd because the site can still be used for the same purpose without hardstandings.
The TC Planning Committee can shout as much as it likes but other statutory consultees have the final say and have better objections. Time and again the TC Planning Committee says one thing and the District Council and other stautory consultees make the decisions.
What is the point of having this utterly useless committee? The argument goes that because the Town Council has the right to be sent all planning applications this means the Town Council should have a say on all these applications and it gives St Neots a say. When the Town Council is ignored time and again then why have this committee?
Many parts of England don't have this level of Parish/Town government and planning gets along just fine. Just because the Town Council has a right doesn't mean it has to exercise this right. Time to get rid of the Town Council Planning Committee and save officer and councillors time on pontificating about planning applications they obviously can do nothing about!
The reason why HDC Planning Officers are recommending refusal is simply another statutory consultee, The Environment Agency, has said it should be refused because the land is liable to flooding. This seems a bit odd because the site can still be used for the same purpose without hardstandings.
The TC Planning Committee can shout as much as it likes but other statutory consultees have the final say and have better objections. Time and again the TC Planning Committee says one thing and the District Council and other stautory consultees make the decisions.
What is the point of having this utterly useless committee? The argument goes that because the Town Council has the right to be sent all planning applications this means the Town Council should have a say on all these applications and it gives St Neots a say. When the Town Council is ignored time and again then why have this committee?
Many parts of England don't have this level of Parish/Town government and planning gets along just fine. Just because the Town Council has a right doesn't mean it has to exercise this right. Time to get rid of the Town Council Planning Committee and save officer and councillors time on pontificating about planning applications they obviously can do nothing about!
Labels:
HDC Planning,
SNTC Planning
Tuesday, November 9, 2010
Useless Town Council Planning Committee being useless again - Part 2
I thought I would follow up on the useless Town Council Planning Committee and the decisions to object to certain planning applications. These were: 1001243FUL - 58 Market Square and 1001611FUL - 11 - 15 Church Street.
1001243FUL is marked for Approval despite the SNTC Planning Committee's Objection. Good. HDC Planning is following its own rules and there is no good reason to Refuse this application.
1001611FUL is also marker for Approval despite SNTC Planning Committee's Objection. This time the planning officer takes time to take apart SNTC objections. These are:
1001243FUL is marked for Approval despite the SNTC Planning Committee's Objection. Good. HDC Planning is following its own rules and there is no good reason to Refuse this application.
1001611FUL is also marker for Approval despite SNTC Planning Committee's Objection. This time the planning officer takes time to take apart SNTC objections. These are:
1
2
HDC says:
3
HDC says:
HDC Planning officers obviously do their best with St Neots Town Council objections. Really this amateurish approach to Planning wastes SNTC and HDC Officers time. It doesn't seem to worry our Councillors that this is adding cost to our Council tax bills.
Labels:
SNTC Planning
Friday, November 5, 2010
Useless Town Council Planning Committee being useless again.
Does the useless Town Council Planning Committee have a problem with the Town Centre? There is always a call for more retail and services and, yet, the Planning Committee is now against video arcades. When the Surgery was proposed, the Town Council Planning Committee bitterly opposed this. It seems when development is proposed in the Town Centre the Town Council is against it.
The old Worx nightclub has gone and the owner wants to change this into something the youth of the Town can use. The opening hours are designed for the place to close at 9pm. This is many hours before the drinking establishments kick out.I feel this is a suitable activity for a Market Town. There is nothing wrong with increased number of youths in the Town. I feel the useless Planning Committee wants the Town Centre to be a museum rather than a working vibrant Town Centre open to all.
Our useless Town Council Planning Committee is also against housing near the Town Centre.
This is not over development. It is in keeping with the area. The useless Town Council Planning Committee uses the old adage "..will create further traffic congestion." An extra 8 houses. No it won't.
Time and again this useless Town Council Planning Committee comes up with some corkers. It should be abolished. This would save officer time and money spent on this committee. In many areas of the country where Town and Parish Councils don't exist then these decisions are taken by the District Council.
What can this Town Council actually do. The CPALC website is very specific. The Town Council has the "Right to be notified of planning applications". The Town Council doesn't have the right to decide planning applications. Nor does the District Council have to take notice of the Town Councils' approvals or objections.
This is a useless committee of the Town Council where some of our Town Councillors can play at being Planners. With no coherent planning policy towards the Town this is a wasteful exercise. Far better to abolish this Committee and free up Officer and Councillor time for matters that they have control over.
This is unlikely to change as Councillors think they can decide Planning Applications and will open up the Town Council to being an ineffective and ridiculed about it decisions. What is also worrying is the Coalition is looking to pass planning decisions down to this level of Government. Being a Liberal Coalition what of the individuals rights over the Community rather than the Governments' rights over the individual?
Labels:
SNTC Planning
Monday, September 13, 2010
Town Council planning back in the spotlight
The amateur Town Council planning committee OBJECTS and the professional HDC planning department recommends approval. The 22 High Street development looks set to get planning approval by HDC. This is a move forward for this part of the Town Centre. But why did the SNTC planning committee object? Below is are the reasons given.
With Town Councillors complaining about all the shops that are vacant in the Town Centre, the Town Councillors want more retail sites?! How perverse. I don't understand what "gross overdevelopment" means when looking at the Town Centre. Isn't that the point of having a Town Centre which is crammed?
Whilst the Town Council has the right to examine and object to Planning Applications, they don't have too. I ask why do they do this? I feel it is well beyond time this waste of money is cut from the budget and the Council Calendar.
With Town Councillors complaining about all the shops that are vacant in the Town Centre, the Town Councillors want more retail sites?! How perverse. I don't understand what "gross overdevelopment" means when looking at the Town Centre. Isn't that the point of having a Town Centre which is crammed?
Whilst the Town Council has the right to examine and object to Planning Applications, they don't have too. I ask why do they do this? I feel it is well beyond time this waste of money is cut from the budget and the Council Calendar.
Labels:
SNTC Planning
Saturday, March 13, 2010
Town Council Planning Committee is a JOKE! - Update.
At the meeting of the Town Council Planning committee on 17/02/10, it was decided to recommend APPROVAL of a planning application for land at the rear of 11-15 Luke Street.
So what does HDC Planning department recommend? Yes, you guessed right - HDC has recommended REFUSAL.
Town Council Planning is a group of Councillors sitting around the table looking at plans. HDC has properly qualified officers who make recommendations on planning policies and law. In my opinion the Town Council should ditch this Committee and save us all a bit of money.
Labels:
SNTC Planning
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














